Well, I've played this adventure without any informations from testing sites and I have to say, it's worth to play, even if there are some contras. After playing I looked for some tests and they are very different, from below average to nearly very good. Here are some minor observations from me:
The game plays in Plymouth, England, in the late 1890s (I think). The background images and graphics are wonderfully designed and rendered; I like this type of graphics in adventures!
Another plus concerns the changing of the person you play: on the one hand the thief who wants to go to America with his friend, on the other the police man for whom duty and honor stands on the highest place. You*ll play both persons and that's again positive, some persons you meet with the first one, you'll meet again with the second; so both storys are well connected.

Now to the negative things: the animations are not very plane, but the cutscenes are high-quality. There are no funny commentaries, when you combine two false things like in other adventures. Some inventory objects do not appear in the real screen, that's not so nice. But the worst thing is the unparallel acting of voice and animations. The persons are moving their lips when there is silence or even when the other person is talking; this sucks.

And then we have the story: it is a good one, needs a lot of time to evolve, but then it's really thrilling. Even if the atmosphere is not as dense as in the former works of the programmers, it's well written. As is the end: you can say it's positive because of the unexpected things happening there (there were hints for a sequel, but that wasn't made, in my eyes), you can say it is negative because it's very abrupt. In my opinion the end has a positive effect on the game!
The other thing is, that the interactions at the end are nearly zero: half an hour of watching and listening, sometimes clicking ... but okay, the story is good!
I played 9 hours or so which is okay.

Maybe I forgot one important point: the puzzles. There are only inventory ones, where you combine objects from there with the screen or with other ones. Two times you have to listen to manage it. But no other types, some kind of frustrating.

Well, that's it from my side, tell me what you have thinked of this game.